Starring: Edward Speleers, Jeremy Irons, Sienna Guillory, Robert Carlyle, John
Malkovich, Rachel Weisz, Chris Egan.
Director: Stefan Fangmeir
Where should I begin? In all fairness, this does seem to be a ‘like it or hate it’ kind of movie. Despite my background as a D & Der (It’s ok to say that now. Vin Diesel is too), I have to align myself with the latter group. Even by the standards of Sword & Sorcery movies (which are not very high), this is damn weak. I do know people who liked it, however (but not my friend who read the books). That is about the nicest thing I can say in its defense.
The story is typical. There is a tyrannical ruler, a resistance group, and one chance to save the world, in the form of a new dragon rider. This rider is a teenager named Eragon, poorly played by Edward Speleers who decided that giving this character a perennial smirk was the way to go. In this world, every dragon must be in the presence of its rider before it will hatch. When one is born, the evil Galbatorix, (Malkovich in small role with a really cheesy name), and his sorcerer henchman, Durza (Robert Carlyle) will stop at nothing to destroy it. I guess evil rulers can’t have any enemy dragons flying around. Lucky for Eragon, he immediately comes across a former dragon rider named Braum played by Jeremy Irons, who deserves an Oscar for being able to deliver his shit lines with passion and a straight face. Braum’s task is to die, I mean serve, as a mentor. Eragon must find and join up with the resistance to give hope and have a chance of surviving himself. If he can, the stage is set for a mighty battle.
This movie has so many weaknesses, I will not be able to discuss them all, but I will try to hit a few lowlights for you. First, a free piece of advice for any aspiring screenwriters out there. When you create a character that has a purpose, but no personality outside of that purpose, you have a cardboard, one-dimensional character. That is bad. It is also pretty much all we have in this whole sorry-ass movie. The story (even the goofy character names) is ok as far this genre goes: nothing new or innovative, but ok. The effects are very good, but in this day and age, that’s expected, not a bonus. The wooden dialogue is as bad as any movie I’ve seen and the plot is full of maddening logic holes that require you to have your brain on low. It tries to rip off Lord of the Rings, but only manages to embarrass itself by drawing comparisons. It is set up for a sequel, and with box office totals of 240 million, it would be a stunning surprise if there weren’t one, although if there isn’t, I would consider it a personal gift from above.
CC: *
In all honesty the only reason I would give this 1 star is because I cannot find the icon that signifies turd. Anyone who says they loved this movie, and there are some out there, eats paste and is fascinated with things that shine in the sun. The last time I had to suspend disbelief this much to make something tolerable was at my prom. The storyline was absolutely forced, and the climax was not even a battle against the real villain, he was back at the castle speaking in a bad accent. The freaky almost erotic dialogue and longing looks between Eragon and the Dragon tripped me out and even the acceptable performance of Jeremy Irons couldn’t hold a single scene together (like he had a snowball’s chance in hell of saving this piece of…nevermind) This “movie” was virtually unbearable from beginnning to end. I mean come on, the cousin who appeared to be a major character at the beginning only to walk off the set and never return, was wearing levi’s. Braums, on foot, out runs a kid on Dragon back and arrives in the exact room of the castle that holds Arya, unseen by anyone mind you, just in time to step in front of the spear magically thrown by the guy from the full monty. I think he should reunite with fat british costars for the Full Monty Part 2 and leave fantasy to Peter Jackson and company. After spending 2 hours watching Eragon, I am looking for “some hot stuff baby tonight”. How about a hot poker to stick in my eye, so I won’t be forced to watch the sequel to this disaster?