Director: Bobby Farrelly, Peter Farrelly
Starring: Ben Stiller, Malin Akerman, Michelle Monaghan, Jerry Stiller, Rob Corddry
This is the lastest in the trend of remaking classic movies with this generations hot stars and an updated edgier feel. Like many of their predecessors, the heartbreak kid and the Farrelly brothers prove that just because an idea was good in 1972, it doesn’t necessarily mean it will translate in 2007.
Ben Stiller plays Eddie Cantrow, a 40 year old single successful man with a serious fear of making the wrong decision when it comes to picking a wife. Because of this, he has a history of ending relationships with pretty good choices because he is not sure that they are his perfect match. He bumps into Lila one day (played by Malin Ackerman) while trying to be a good samaritan and help her retrieve her handbag from a purse snatcher. They start dating and soon after, unique events lead Eddie to be put in a position where he has to marry her or lose her. Prompted by his own fear that he is letting another winner slip away and the incessant digs from his father played by appropriately and believably by Jerry Stiller and constant coercing by his best friend Mac played by Rob Corddry, Eddie decides to take the plunge. Almost within minutes he realizes that it was not the correct decision.
Movies that involve the Farrelly brothers and movies that involve Ben Stiller usually run a pretty similar path, not everyone will like them and they will not winner a lot of Oscar’s but generally you can count on a couple of times per hour that you are in a full “belly laugh”. Now, those laughs are not always of the highbrow variety, they are often jokes involving strange noises, inappropriate sex or bodily fluids, but heartbreak had none of those moments. Well that isn;t entirely true, there were jokes about weird noises and inappropriate sex but they more disturbing than funny. Additionally, it just was so obvious that they were trying to mimic the successful formula of “There’s Something About Mary” (right down to using a female lead that could pass as Cameron Diaz at Cameron Diaz’s own family Christmas) that it was almost uncomfortable. Now, I can buy the idea that all “romantic comedies” have to have some sort of a “musical interlude”, fun activity montage to show how the relationship is developing, however, no movie goer should ever have to endure 2! The truth about Ben Stiller is the true heartbreak. As much as I really want to love his movies because I really like him in the right roles, unless he is surrounded by real talent, like the Deniros , Dillons and Robin Williams’ of the world, he cannot carry a movie.
Skip the 7 dollar ticket, go to 7-11 buy an extra big box of junior mints and a big gulp and go home. If you flip channels long enough you’ll probably find “There’s Something About Mary” on TBS.
MMM says:
The Farrelly brothers, who brought us such entertaining hits as There’s Something About Mary and, Dumb and Dumber, as well as junkers like Fever Pitch, are back at it with another disappointing Stiller film that is as hit and miss as a 70s sitcom. The premise is a little shaky to begin with, but they manage to hold it together and get an equal number of giggles and groans until the last half hour, which is as fun as a summer road trip through Iraq. It’s a mess and took away any generous feelings that I had toward the film. This film isn’t really much different than what we have come to expect from the always crude, and sometimes funny, Farrelly brothers, but I spent so much time grimacing in the last half hour that if felt like a dental appointment.
Ben Stiller is Eddie Cantrow, a sports store owner who feels like the only single man left in America when he meets a gorgeous mid-twenties good hearted dream girl, Lila, played by Swedish-born Malin Akerman. The pressure of circumstances, friends and his crude father, played real-life Pa, Jerry Stiller of Seinfeld fame, leads to a sudden wedding after six weeks of dating (during which time, Eddie apparently learned absolutely nothing about his bride-to-be). They set off on a Mexican honeymoon, during which Eddie learns that his beautiful, new bride is a sexual pretzel with attachment issues like a whiny puppy and a past with as many issues as a Nazi war criminal. Things get more complicated when he meets a smart, funny and beautiful lacrosse coach, Miranda, played by Michelle Monaghan. So what happens when you find your real true love while you are on your honeymoon? Can you say awkward? What ensues is an uneven story that unfolds like one of those sitcoms where the main character has two dates at once. The wheels fall off in the last half hour, but there is a ballsy, slightly non-formula ending.
The usual Farrelly brothers crowd will like this one. This crowd usually consists of the same adolescent minds that like Ben Stiller movies, but if you are not already a fan of these guys, then this one is sure not going to win you over.